Question:
Should I stay married or get a divorce.?
Hilda C
2006-09-16 23:50:11 UTC
We've been married for 21 years. This last anniversary, neither one of us remembered.We have 3 kids. The oldest will be going off to college next year. He's a Dr. and is personable and is very nice looking. I have survived a potential affair from his part and my breast cancer. I have been for the most part on my own for emotional support. He is a wonderful father, and provider but bad works hard and works many hours.I have had to hear for 15 years how he's the only bread winner.Now that I've entered the work force, he's putting my job down. I worked over time to the point of being burnt out while he went to medical school. And now that I have started working again, just after going through Chemo and Radiation, family and friends say that I look like I am glowing! It's because I love my job. He's anal about everything, obsessive compulsive,controlling and condesending. We are so different and I am totally turned off by him. I can't even kiss him anymore.But I can't hurt our kids.
32 answers:
Dody
2006-09-17 00:06:41 UTC
You wont get a second time around remember that , and I dont think you want to leave this world with all the regrets of things you love and wanted to do ,your kids are old enough to handle things ,besides I think they will understand or will eventually its impossible that they haven't noticed the change in you and the joy that your job is giving you, you have given your best years to your family , and if your husband is so greedy to not understand your personal needs they he doesnt deserve you ,take a deep breath , take the step forward if you have thought it out , and follow your dream if this is what you want , no-one should can condem you for wanting to live and breath on your own, I personally wish you the very best ,
Phantom Viper
2006-09-17 00:07:45 UTC
Whilst i perfectly realise and undstand u not wanting to hurt ur kids, u also have to realise that u cant live your life for your kids. The eldest is going to college soon and should be of some maturity to be honest, im not sure how old the other 2 are but im sure they are of some intelligence. As for your hubby, read ur question and see what he has done, he has let u deal with a cancer situation with little or no supprt. to be honest i think this bloke is a **** er, it doesnt matter what he looks like to how he is to the public, what counts is how is is as a husband ! he is even showing his colours now by driving down ur new job ! personally i take my hat off to you and u deserve hearty congratualtions, not only have u been thru chemo which is known to be very physially draining not to mention emotoinally but also u have had the balls to get up when u can and go find a job, im amazed at ur hubby considering his whining constantly for 15yrs of bieng the only bread winner. I would think he would of been happy for you. See what he is enjoying is the fact that he CAN complain bout it because it makes u feel like shyte, but now u have a job uve taken that away and thats y he is demeaning u and ur job !And it seems he is forgetting the sacrifice u made when he was in med school ? Im personally in awe of after what u have been thru to come out the other side with such confidence to go get a job and to enjoy life ! Your familly and friends can obviously see the difference. I would leave this guy at the earliset opportunity, and even if u have to save with your new job u know have the means to do so. As for the kids ? Which is better? 2 paretns that are together and constantly sniping and back biting? or 2 that are plit but united in loving and rainsing thier kids to the best of thier ability ? Ask yourself, if u stay in this marridge are u sure ur not hurting the kids ? or are u doing them more damage? The decision is ultimatly yours, but i know which way i wud turn, good luck to you and once again congratulations on ur new job u deserve the happiest of outcomes :)
Marna S
2006-09-17 00:01:33 UTC
First of all, I am not a expert.But I have been with the same man, since I was 16, I am now 39.We have only been married for eleven years, because he has always had a strange fear about things working out, plus it has taken him a long time to GROW up, anyway, think back to the reason that brought you and him together?And I totally understand your misery of going through the whole cancer treatments! I feel like he is Old school,in that catergory, woman don't really have a actual job, unless the husband and children are involved.He as a man, needs to realize you need to work and to feel important and needed.After all, men are lost without us! I speak from first hand experience.I hope this helps you? Again, I am not in anyway a expert!!!!!!! Trust your own feelings???????????????????? I hope and pray ever thing works out for you!
anonymous
2006-09-17 00:54:34 UTC
No relationship is worth staying together just because of your children...That is the wrong thing. I know most people believe in staying married and i to am married and sometimes as a women we feel its easier to stay married just because we feel bad for our children. Not just that but also we tend to feel we have been married so long that maybe we cant due it on our own....WRONG we can and if you are happy with your new job then congrats...Your one step closer to being more happy.. At the end of the day we should be coming home from work to an exciting life. Not to some controlling husband who puts your job or you down and makes you feel small...You have to think about yourself to. You did a good job and raised your children already its time for you to live a Lil. Have fun dont be miserable...
Jerry
2006-09-17 00:28:46 UTC
Wow.



Firstly, congratulations on 21 years of marriage. That's indisputable commitment.



If you can stay and work it out, if you WANT to, then do it. Tell him the truth. Tell him he's turned into something that completely turns you off, and if your marriage is to survive you're going to have to go to counseling.



As far as your observations of him, try not to let them out except at therapy. Accept the fact that you might also be suffering from a little myopathy. I don't care if you're married to a PRINCE, after 21 years, you'll be intimately familiar with EVERY LITTLE FLAW. And we all got plenty of 'em, let me tell ya!



If you can't do it, if you just cannot deal with it, then your argument about doing it for the kids is a classic BAD EXAMPLE. Don't do it for the kids. You're not helping them, your'e showing them how they should live their lives, because children learn by example and not by what you say. Is this what you would want YOUR children to do in this situation?



I'm so sorry you're going through this. Best of luck to you, and have the courage to do what you know is right.
rood
2016-10-15 06:12:45 UTC
while i found out that each and on a daily basis that handed that i became unhappy became yet another day in my life that i wouldn't in any respect come again, i desperate to not waste any further of my priceless days on a hopeless challenge. I chosen to divorce and became happy I did. life is merely too short to stay depressing once you have the choice to interrupt loose and commence as quickly as greater. 2 years once I have been given divorced, I met the genuine love of my life, and function been fortunately married merely approximately 2 many years now. If I hadn't made the determination to circulate away the loser, i wouldn't in any respect have met and married the winner.
jay
2006-09-17 03:42:55 UTC
Wow! You are going thru some very trying and emotional times but at the same time some soul searching opportunities for personal growth wisdom and understanding.



I dont profess to know what to say to you that could help but I will give my thoughts.



From what you have written this man is:



Positives:

Personable, Nice Looking, A Wonderful Father, Hard Worker, A Bread Winner for 15 years, A Doctor.



Comment:

Not bad for a guy who has worked hard for his family and himself...seems dedicated to work and in his own way to his family. I think he would feel he has contributed a lot to you and your relationship together and to his family materially.



Negatives:

Not emotionally there, Works too many hours, Critical, Obsessive, Compulsive, Controlling, Condescending.



Comment:

Driving this mans negatives is fear.

I think he doesn't know how to handle emotions well and would find it difficult to communicate on that level as most males lack the skills in that department and much less know how to bridge any gap they feel is happening in their relationship.

I think his answer to that was to have an affair looking for understanding and solace. This of course would have done the opposite to what he might have thought. This act would have alienated you from him further.

I feel he would also know he hasn't been exactly supportive and understanding of you and would be feeling desperately afraid of losing you.



Currently

Comments:

You have been supportive in your early times together and kept the home fires burning, have gone thru cancer and treatments feeling unsupported probably deeply hurt and lonely at times having to deal with facing a possible death sentence on your own. You have empowered yourself with employment and are looking and feeling good.



It would seem to me that you would like independence and freedom but would still like the stability a family gives you as by your statement "I cant hurt the kids'.



I do feel that this is a good relationship that is worth saving and can be fixed by good communication which brings understanding and healing as a result.



The services of a good counsellor would be beneficial in my view.



The first step in turning this around is for the two of you to recognise together that:

a) The relationship will not survive if you don't both recognise that it is worth saving.

b) Committing yourselves to doing just that by enlisting professional help.



Additional comments

I believe that only part of your feeling good is attributable to your employment and sudden independence although it is the trigger for other things, such as self empowerment, a raised self esteem, an augmented self worth and a feeling of attractiveness.



This new energy would radiate from you making you also more attractive to the opposite sex and any compliments received about how you look would no doubt add more to your feelings of sexiness, niceness and attractiveness.

This would in turn have the effect of making you vulnerable to flirting and interested males which you could find a little difficult to repel when you compare it to what you have at home. "I cant even kiss him anymore."



While affairs can happen for many reasons it is often a short term escape from the responsibilities of a relationship that has grown heavy with disappointments, hurts and pain in many areas of need and closeness which are definitely lacking.



Affairs can feel absolutely freeing and mind blowingly enjoyable (I know from experience) so much so that it is easy for one to think they made a mistake in their marriage and want out as quickly as possible.

That the lover is so wonderful and doesn't have the traits and problems that has caused the marriage to feel more like a prison than a happy relationship.

Often when the lovers have changed that relationship to a committed one the new marriage flounders with what may appear as different problems but underlying it are the very same unresolved issues that caused the previous marriage to flounder.



If you wish to email me you are welcome.
anonymous
2006-09-16 23:58:51 UTC
Absolutely...you're right...you can't hurt the kids. You're thinking in the right direction. Use your busy work schedule as a way to get away from this than really getting away from it . Divorce is the easy way out......instead you want to teach your kids to be strong and to never give up trying....and the importance of working hard on a relationship you've spent 21 years building. Take care!
Michael
2006-09-16 23:54:32 UTC
Of course no one can really tell you what to do only make suggestions, so here is mine, I was a cancer patient, probably in a situation like yours only I am a man, all stress and no play makes for a dull life and relationship, the doctor told me I had about 2 years at most, so I changed my life, divorced, sold my house and gave my business away to my wife, moved away from everyone to a strange place, met new friends a new lover etc, I have been cancer free now for 12 years, my doctor has since died! My suggestion, get out live your life it is too short, let your children live theirs, they will be around long after your gone! Good Luck!
brendalyn
2006-09-17 00:23:54 UTC
He sounds like a control freak and an inconsiderate jerk. If you value your self esteem and your health, get out of this toxic relationship. I went through a similar experience, and it took me 15 years to wake up. I'm much happier and healthier for it, and my kids have noticed that too. If you think that your staying in the relationship is helping by hiding your true feelings from the children, you are only fooling yourself. Kids see through it all, and will be happier knowing that you are happy. Best of luck in your choice and in your life.
anonymous
2006-09-17 00:18:24 UTC
A wonderful father,plus a provider minus a husband, lover and a friend equals (a roommate) with par-time benefits.The kids are already in pain it's time for some damage control savage what you can-sometime having peace of mind and heart is more valuable.
donna r
2006-09-17 01:29:23 UTC
Chances are, if you're unhappy he is too. If he's already had one affair, there may be others you don't know about. Men at this stage of life often dump their current wives for a younger version, known as the 20 year ditch. It happened to me after 25 years of marriage. I can't make this decision for you but this is my advice:

1. Most important, find out what the divorce laws are in your state and protect yourself financially. Once you separate, you may no longer have access to your assets, such as checking, savings, CDs, stocks or bonds.

2. In most states, you can take money out of joint accounts and open new accounts in your name only, or withdraw funds and put them in a safe depost box that is in your name only. Once you separate, it's likely he will cut you off from any funds you hold jointly.

3. If you have insurance policies with cash values, cash them in now before you make a move; it is legal while you're married. You can also place liens on any assets so that once they're sold, the lien has to be satisfied first before splitting it with your husband.

4. Being a doctor, he will probably get the best divorce lawyer money can buy. His lawyer will advise him to take steps to keep as much of your assets as he can, cutting you off from everything acqured during your marriage, including credit cards.

5. If there are things you want to keep, such as jewelry, document these as gifts and they are no longer considered community property, including cars etc.

6. The internet is a good source for information about divorce laws in any state. Also, since you work, don't count on alimony if you make at least $1000 a month, that's why you should take steps now to secure enough funds to survive. Remember, you have a right to any and all assets acquired during your marriage. You may also be held responsible for half of the debts you have now. That's where the liens come into play.

6. Your children probably sense something is wrong in your marriage and in the end they will want you to be happy.

7. Remember, you worked hard to put him through medical school and you have the right to take care of yourself financially because he will do whatever it takes to make sure you don't get a penny.

8. Don't confide in anyone before you know your rights, your best friend may turn out to be your worst enemy. Be your own best friend and protect yourself and your children. Be aware he may try to get custody, so be careful in that regard.

9. If you decide to do this, it may get rough at times, and a man will tell you what you want to hear-they are very good at this. Don't let him con you that things will be different, they don't change.

10. Your marriage will only survive if both of you work on it, so if he's not interested take care of yourself and don't rely on any promises he might make. Good luck, and remember you have a right to be happy. You only get one life.
anonymous
2006-09-16 23:55:11 UTC
You should really get a divorce. Being with someone who is controlling is NOT good at all. It could ruin your relationships in the future and trust me, i learned the hard way. It may hurt the kids but it will hurt them more if you stay with him and arn't happy. They will eventually understand. Good luck and I hope everything works out for you!
ξℓ Çђαηφσ
2006-09-17 00:03:08 UTC
ok, hold on...i know u dont want to hurt ur kids...but if ur fighting w/ him and if the relationship is very rocky...and the kids are seeing this...then the best thing to do is get a divorce...my parents just got a divorce this summer...(im 17) in a way i though it was the end of the world...but on the other hand...i knew my parents werent happy and things were getting worse between them. when they got the divorce, i was relieved b/c i couldnt handle all their fighting anymore (it lasted like four yrs...) i was going crazy...but like i said, when it happened...i was so relieved...and now i see both of them and everyone is happy...(i still wish it didnt happen but...thats life) but enough about my drama...

it seems like u NEED to leave him...the second someone tells me they are the breadwinner....OMG....thats it...i dont know but im sure u took care of ur kids, cleaned the house, did the laundry, cooked...so that means nothing??? I DONT THINK SO!! It means a lot...maybe ur husband took it for granted...and u know what, u made a big mistake...u werent working...my mom made the same mistake...now she's working her butt off trying to get her nursing license...(shes in PR, my dad in PA, and im in NJ) i live w/ my aunt for now until she gets back...big mess w/ us...if u dont feel anything for him...get the divorce...its not good to stay w/ someone if the relationship is like that. it WILL be hard...it hit my mom and i VERY HARD...but we are slowly moving on and things are starting to get WAY BETTER...lol...

but in the end it is ur decision...think about what i said...and i really hope things go well w/ ur cancer...



completely off subject...but if u need to cut them off to survive...CUT THEM OFF...so what ur flat chested...at least u aint dead! =)
Kuji
2006-09-16 23:54:38 UTC
I wouldn't stay with him just for the kids but you don't really sound ready to leave yet. Why not stay in the house but lead your own life the way your husband does and just mostly ignore him? Eventually, either he'll decide to make an effort or you'll decide you really have had enough and get your own place.
day
2006-09-16 23:59:47 UTC
I have been asking myself the same question. But if he was not there for you while undergoing chemo....and he is a dr.. lets just say as a nurse I would not want to be working with him. Dump him life is so short and the babies can handle it.
oneblondepilgrim
2006-09-16 23:54:47 UTC
I would think that a scare with breast cancer would have opened your eyes to how precious life is.. that fact that you are even asking should you get a divorce, says that you probably want to. Your kids will get over it.. Start living your life the way you want to.
anonymous
2006-09-17 01:33:30 UTC
So you're in a miserable marriage, want out obviously but are going to use your children as the means to stay married? What a great thing for a parent to do, make yourself a martyr for their sakes...if you're so miserable get out of the marriage rather than blaming your children for staying in it.
Veevee
2006-09-16 23:58:49 UTC
What's with u? Can't hurt the kids or afraid to go throught a break up...if u can't get your husband to respond to you and the marriage, u both are in a committed marriage..then maybe u need to be on your own looking after your own needs and finding supportive people to be around. u know..don't u dear? it's time.

take care
konala
2006-09-16 23:55:10 UTC
Your kids will survive a divorce. They are big enough. Many people divorce after many years of marriage and wonder why they had not done it years sooner. You only have one life and should not be spent in misery.
anonymous
2006-09-16 23:58:50 UTC
sounds like your kids might be old enough to understand how you feel and never stay in a marriage for kids , they will be fine.I would never advise someone to stay Miserable , which is what you are.Tell him you are thinkin of divorce and maybe he'll wake up and change some things or maybe not in which case you have to try to be happy even if it means divorcing him! best of luck.
anonymous
2006-09-17 00:23:52 UTC
Baby, you need to keep pray and keep stay married.

As a statement said if "You are gone, but never forgotten. You are near, but yet so far away. You love and memory will stay with you always".

GBU n ur family.
Stephanie
2006-09-16 23:56:02 UTC
If you aren't happy, there is little point in missing out on life. But maybe you could try couples counselling first.
anonymous
2006-09-17 00:12:09 UTC
That sucks. i dont know....

If the cancer might cumm (Ha Ha Get It.) back then, no.

Because you might need his $ bag(since he acks like it) and that would have to better for the kids. and you.



Congrad's on the job.

Shine on.



P.S.

Contact me if you get horney.
Jen G
2006-09-16 23:53:21 UTC
Your kids sound they are old enough to handle it. Do whatever makes you happy, you only live once.
Lisa L
2006-09-16 23:59:42 UTC
Would you rather them see you be miserable, that's not good for them or you either.What do you feel, honestly in your heart?
?
2006-09-16 23:56:29 UTC
You and I have soooooooooo much in common.
☠Naz☠
2006-09-16 23:53:47 UTC
This is something only your heart can truly answer....
jv637
2006-09-16 23:52:41 UTC
follow your heart & make your decision.
jdwest67
2006-09-17 00:36:42 UTC
get rid of him
vick
2006-09-17 00:13:17 UTC
if you love him stay-- if you don't, leave
d_guy67
2006-09-17 00:04:21 UTC
GET YOURSELF INTO COUNSELING ---NOW!!!!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...